Magic: The Gathering - Battlegrounds cover art

Magic: The Gathering - Battlegrounds

Real-time spell duels resting on spellbook construction and opponent prediction.

Here's the argument for where this game sits - disagree freely.
Match your experience?
EXECUTION5 /10READS4 /10VARIANCE3 /10OPTIMIZATION6 /10

the cheat-test profile

The four axes - the argument

Each axis is rated on its own - how far one cheat would trivialize the game here. They don't trade off; low on all four means the game is an experience, not a contest.

  1. Execution

    cheat: Aimbot - perfect inputs

    5/10

    Real-time dodging and cast timing matter in duels

  2. Reads

    cheat: Out-predict an adaptive opponent

    4/10

    Human duelists feint summons and bait counterspells

  3. Variance

    cheat: See what's hidden / map the RNG

    3/10

    Opponent spellbook is hidden until revealed in duel

  4. Optimization

    cheat: A perfect solver / coach

    6/10

    Spellbook construction and mana curves are solvable

How to read this

Each axis is named by the cheat that would break the game along it. Execution is the hands. Reads is out-thinking an adaptive opponent. Variance is hidden information & RNG. Optimization is the solvable systems layer. A game's region is the top one or two axes.

These four aren't one rating split four ways - they're independent 0-10 questions. A 9 on one axis takes nothing from the others, and a game low on all four isn't missing data: it's telling you there's no skill here to cheat.

The basis is how the majority actually plays this game - not a niche mode or a personal run. For a game with very different modes (a story campaign versus ranked multiplayer), that's the version most people mean.

Compare with

Similar games

see all →

Ranked by shared genre first, then by how closely the cheat-test profile matches - a cross-genre tag means a pick matched on skill profile alone.

Warcraft: Orcs & Humans cover art

Warcraft: Orcs & Humans

Practiced Mastery · real-time strategy

E
R
V
O
Warcraft: Orcs & Humans
Dragon Ball: Xenoverse 2 cover art

Dragon Ball: Xenoverse 2

Practiced Mastery · anime arena fighter

E
R
V
O
Dragon Ball: Xenoverse 2
Command & Conquer: Red Alert cover art

Command & Conquer: Red Alert

Pure Optimization · real-time strategy

E
R
V
O
Command & Conquer: Red Alert
The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth II cover art

The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth II

Practiced Mastery · real-time strategy

E
R
V
O
The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth II
Brütal Legend cover art

Brütal Legend

Practiced Mastery · action RTS hybrid

E
R
V
O
Brütal Legend
Total War: Rome II cover art

Total War: Rome II

Pure Optimization · historical strategy wargame

E
R
V
O
Total War: Rome II

Game details

Released
2003
Developer
Secret Level
Franchise
Magic: The Gathering
Platforms
XBOX, PC
Modes
Single player, Multiplayer, Split screen
IGDB critics
80/100
IGDB users
55/100
FightingReal Time Strategy (RTS)Action